Robin's Lost Trinket
*You must first complete the quest, Demetrius' Poetry Woes*
- Location: Rider Isle
- Items Required: none
-
Reward: 50 Quest Points, $5,000, Dinosaur Bone, Mouse or Seashell Necklace
After you have helped Demetrius with his writer's block, return to Robin the elf in his willow tree home east of Witherton. If you've forgotten Robin's location, you can find him by using your shovel to dig in the spot indicated to the left. Ask Robin how he's doing, and he will tell you that he's been worried about having misplaced his wishing box. Offer to help find it for him, and he will inform you that he last had it near a rock in the forest above his home.
Exit Robin's tree and head north into Bridle Forest. Toward the eastern edge of the woods, you will see a large boulder surrounded several smaller rock piles, as seen below. 
Search the rock piles here until you locate Rose, a beautiful maiden. She wanders a bit, but shouldn't be too hard to track down. Once you've found her, ask if she has seen Robin's magical trinket lying around - she will tell you that she has and will gladly return it to you.
Take the wishing box back to Robin, who will be so grateful that he allows you to use the box to wish for your choice of a reward. You can pick either a Dinosaur Bone, a Mouse companion, or a Seashell Necklace. Choose whichever one you like in order to complete the quest.
Sabella's Mare, Apples
- Location: Appleton (Horse Isle)
- Items Required: none
-
Reward: 200 Quest Points, $50,000
To start the quest, talk to Sabella in Appleton. She will tell you that her favorite horse, Apples, has gone missing. Offer to help her look for clues, then exit her cabin and use your Magnifying Glass in the spot indicated to the right. Once you've located a set of footprints, return to Sabella and let her know. She will tell you to ask the residents of town if they've seen anything suspicious.
The first person you should speak to is Reuben the clown, who will tell you that he saw a little boy leading Apples earlier in the day. Reuben will also suggest that you travel into the forest just east of Appleton in order to pay a visit to Faustus, who might know which direction the pair went.
Unfortunately for you, Faustus will refuse to tell you anything until you've given him some apple pie, which you will have to retrieve from Sabella in order to proceed. Properly bribed, Faustus will finally inform you that he saw a boy called Elliott leading an appaloosa into the meadow below his house.
Elliott wanders the clearing directly below Faustus' cabin, so comb the area for him. When you find him, he will return Apples to you. Take her back to Sabella to complete the quest.
Trigger's Tack
- Location: Horse Isle
- Items Required: none
-
Reward: 300 Quest Points, $35,000
Trigger can be found at the edge of Mane Forest on Horse Isle, just a few steps to the west of the door to the Pony Express Headquarters. Speak to him to learn that he has misplaced several pieces of his tack and needs help relocating them. The first item Trigger will ask you to find is his saddle pad, which he thinks he misplaced while on Dolphin Isle. Travel there and speak to Waverly, one of the Flipperton residents, who will tell you to check Trigger's camp site near Blow Hole Forest. Head north until you see a small stand of trees next to an empty house, and use your Magnifying Glass next to the dead tree as shown to the right. You will find the lost saddle pad as well as a leaflet which you should take back to Trigger. He will give you $2,000 for your troubles so far.
Next, Trigger will ask you to check Wington for his bridle. Speak to Iris Pettel, owner of the flower shop in Wington, who will tell you that Daf found the bridle and is holding onto it. Daf lives in a cottage west of the flower shop, so head over and retrieve the second piece of lost tack from her, then return it to Trigger. He will tip you another $3,000.
Lastly, you must find Trigger's saddle, which he thinks he lost beneath the willow tree on Hoof Isle. The tree is located on the north side of the isle, next to a small pond. Use your Binoculars in the spot indicated to the left in order to find Trigger's final piece of missing tack, then return it to him to complete the quest.
Truffles for Cara Cook
*You must first complete the quest, Cara's Lost Niece*
- Location: Wington (Bird Isle)
- Items Required: none
-
Reward: 175 Quest Points, $60,000
After you've helped Cara find her missing niece, return to her and ask if there is anything else she needs help with. She will tell you that she needs truffles to replace the ones that Zoe mistakenly threw away and will ask you to get some from Fritz on Saddle Isle.
Fritz lives in a small house below Cantle Meadows, just on the edge of Mystic Forest. Tell Fritz that Cara has sent you for a dozen truffles, and he will inform you that he only has six. He will ask you to help him find the rest of the truffles for Cara and will lend you Ruffles the pig, who has been trained to seek them out. You will need to enter the Mystic Forest maze and find Ruffles at various points along the path, then use your rake to uncover the truffles. The images below show all six of Ruffles' locations. You can also reference this map of Saddle Isle if you need help finding your way through the maze.
Once you've gathered all six truffles from the maze, return to Fritz. He will let you keep the truffles you found for free and will sell you the remaining six for $500 a piece. With your dozen truffles in hand, head back to Cara in order to complete the quest.